The Secret Hand of God

By Dr. Eli Lizorkin-Girzhel

Thank you to my friends for your support!

Did you know that the Book of Esther presents a profound paradox: it is one of only two books in the traditional Hebrew Bible where God is never mentioned. No divine voice thunders from Sinai, no prophet declares “Thus says the Lord,” and no miracle parts seas. However, this very absence serves as the backdrop for a profound lesson in providence. Esther reveals how God works not through dramatic supernatural interventions, but through the seemingly ordinary—and often deeply flawed—decisions of kings, the courage of individuals, and the “coincidences” of timing.

A World of Hollow Power

The story unfolds in the Persian Empire under King Ahasuerus (likely Xerxes I, 486–465 BCE), a ruler whose power is both absolute and fragile. He opens with lavish banquets showcasing his wealth (Esther 1:1-5), yet his sovereignty is immediately challenged when Queen Vashti refuses his command to appear before his drunken guests (1:12). His advisors, fearing widespread rebellion, persuade him to banish Vashti and issue an empire-wide decree that enforces abusive male “leadership” (1:17-22). This is a world where law masks insecurity, where power is performative yet easily threatened.

Into this volatile empire step Mordecai and his orphaned cousin, living as exiled Jews in the land of their captors (2:5-7). The young woman has two identities: her Hebrew name Hadassah (הֲדַסָּה), meaning “myrtle”—a plant whose leaves hide its fragrance until crushed—and her Persian name Esther (אֶסְתֵּר), which either means “star” or “Ishtar,” a famous Persian goddess. However, in her native language (Hebrew), this new Persian name sounds like the word that means “hidden or concealed” (ס-ת-ר).

At Mordecai’s instruction, she conceals her Judean ethnicity and cultural identity (2:10), a secret she maintains even after being taken into the king’s harem, undergoing a year of beauty preparations, and ultimately being chosen as queen (2:17).

The Unresolved Tension

Here lies the story’s first and most unsettling tension: a Jewish woman is taken into a pagan king’s harem, subjected to sexual vetting among, no doubt, other tests to eventually gain his favor, and marries him—actions that clearly violate Torah prohibitions against intermarriage and sexual relations outside of permitted marriage (Deuteronomy 7:3-4). The narrative offers no direct judgment (think Tamar getting pregnant by Judah, Rahab being a sex worker, Ruth “uncovering the feet” of Boaz, etc.). Instead, it highlights the coercive reality of imperial power, where a vulnerable young woman in Mordecai’s guardianship likely had no meaningful choice.

This intentional ambiguity forces readers to grapple with profound questions: Can divine purpose work through morally compromised circumstances? What is the relationship between survival and faithfulness? The text refuses easy answers, immersing us instead in the messy reality of exile, where conventional morality collides with brute power.

When Evil Wears the Crown

The tension escalates with the rise of Haman, the Agagite. His identification as an Agagite is profoundly significant, connecting his plot to the ancient feud between Israelites and the Amalekites (Haman was a descendant of King Agag, 1 Sam 15). The result is not merely personal dislike of Mordechai, but all of the people of Judea exiled and now residing in Persian lands. The intent is Israel’s annihilation. Nothing less. Incidentally, a Jew here is not a person of Jewish faith, as would be the case today. Instead, it refers to a group of Judeans (and anyone perceived to be from the ancestral land of Israel) who were exiled and enslaved.

Haman’s pride demands universal homage. Mordecai, sitting at the king’s gate, refuses (3:2). The text doesn’t specify why, only noting it relates to his Judean ancestry (3:4). Enraged, Haman determines to destroy not just Mordecai but all his people. Given their ancient “connection,” this makes perfect sense.

Here the story takes its dark turn. Haman manipulates the king with strategic lies: “There is a certain people scattered and dispersed among the peoples… their laws are different from those of all other people, and they do not comply with the king’s laws” (3:8). A decree is written, sealed with the king’s signet ring, and dispatched to every province: on the thirteenth of Adar, the people are to “destroy, kill, and annihilate all the Judeans/Jews… and to seize their possessions as plunder” (3:13). The law of the Medes and Persians cannot be repealed (8:8). The machinery of absolute, legalized evil is set in motion. Can anything or anyone intervene?

“For Such a Time as This”

When Mordecai learns of the decree, he tears his clothes, dons sackcloth and ashes, and wails loudly at the king’s gate (4:1-2). Esther, sheltered in the palace, initially hesitates when urged to intervene. Her response reveals her deep fear: approaching the king without an invitation would likely lead to death, unless he graciously extends his golden scepter to the uninvited “guest.” The fact that he did not summon her for about a month compounded the problem (4:11). Did she lose his favor already? If only this challenge would have come one month earlier. But what could she do? It was simply too dangerous and reckless.

Mordecai’s answer contains the theological heart of the book:

“Do not imagine that you in the king’s palace can escape any more than all the Jews. For if you keep silent at this time, relief and deliverance will arise for the Jews from another place, but you and your father’s house will perish. And who knows whether you have not attained royalty for such a time as this?” (4:13-14).

Two foundational pillars of providence emerge here. First, God’s purpose is unstoppable. “Deliverance will arise from another place.” The survival of God’s covenant people doesn’t depend on one person’s courage or lack thereof. The God of Abraham is faithful to His promise to preserve Israel, with or without Esther.

Second, God’s providence is participatory. “Perhaps you attained royalty for such a time as this.” Esther’s perilous position—her beauty, her sexuality, her pleasant character, her favor with the king, even her hidden identity—is reconsidered. What seemed like random circumstance (or moral compromise) now appears as a divine appointment. Her entire life, with all its moral ambiguities, is retrospectively invested with purpose.

Esther’s faith is on full display. She takes nothing for granted: “Go, gather all the Judeans… fast for me; do not eat or drink for three days… I and my attendants also will fast… And so I will go to the king, which is not in accordance with the law; and if I perish, I perish” (4:16).

The risk is high. But it is now fully surrendered to Israel’s God.

Sovereignty in the Shadows

What follows is a breathtaking sequence of “coincidences” woven together by an unseen hand:

Esther finds favor before the king, who extends his golden scepter (5:2). Displaying strategic wisdom, she postpones her plea, inviting the king and Haman to two successive banquets instead (5:4-8). This intentional delay sets everything in motion.

That very night, the king suffers insomnia (6:1). As he consults the royal chronicles, he hears of Mordecai’s unrewarded loyalty from five years earlier (6:2-3). Meanwhile, Haman arrives at the palace intending to secure Mordecai’s death, only to be forced by the king to publicly honor the very man he seeks to destroy (6:6-11). The devastating blow to Haman’s pride perfectly prepares for the second banquet, where Esther finally reveals her identity: “For we have been sold (referring to the 10000 talents of silver Haman promised to King’s treasury as a result of the crackdown in 3:8-9), I and my people, to be destroyed” (7:4).

The king’s fury drives him into the garden. Haman, in a desperate plea, falls upon Esther’s couch. The king misinterprets this incident as sexual assault and orders Haman executed on the very gallows he had prepared for Mordecai (7:7-10).

The Hidden Star and the Crushed Myrtle

The Book of Esther ultimately gives us a powerful and practical hope: God is at work even when He seems most absent. Our lives are often filled with ordinary decisions, difficult compromises, and confusing timing. Esther’s story reassures us that these are not signs that God has abandoned us. Instead, they can be the very tools He uses to position us for a crucial purpose we cannot yet see. It teaches us that our past mistakes, our current circumstances, and our background are very significant.

Our moments of risk, flawed histories, and faith-filled (or faithless) seasons are woven into a design we often cannot see, much like the hidden star or the crushed myrtle that releases its scent only when pressed. The Book of Esther teaches that each of us, regardless of how compromised our position may be, has the potential, at a crucial moment in our life, to sacrifice everything to do what is right.

The rhetorical question still hangs in the air: “And who knows whether you have not come to the kingdom for such a time as this?”